Putting [our] research in front of the Commission during a live rulemaking is exactly the kind of contribution scholars should be making.
Professor Andrea Johnson
New York Law School
Workplace Law scholars Stacy Hawkins (Rutgers), Andrea J. Johnson (New York Law) and Shirley Lin (Brooklyn) submitted a public comment to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), opposing its proposed rescission of the EEO-1 workforce demographic reporting requirements. Nearly 120 law and social science professors with expertise in workplace law, civil rights and the social sciences signed on.
The authors argue that rescinding EEO-1 Reporting would eliminate a valuable, low-burden data collection system that has supported Title VII compliance and enforcement for sixty years. EEO reporting enables private litigants to bring pattern-or-practice claims, establishes a critical public research record, and shapes the EEOC’s own strategic enforcement priorities. The authors critique the proposal’s cost-benefit analysis for ignoring the harm rescission poses to these important legal and research interests. And they reject the EEOC’s purported justification, asserting that neither Title VII nor the Equal Protection Clause condemns voluntary self-identification or aspires to the form of “colorblindness” the agency espouses.
Hawkins, Johnson and Lin’s filing joins nearly 1,500 comments submitted on the docket and adds an extensive scholarly record to a rulemaking that has drawn opposition from civil rights organizations, plaintiffs’ and employer-side bar groups, and researchers alike. The authors note the importance of academics putting their work to use in a moment when, as Professor Johnson describes it, the “[current presidential] administration is dismantling and redirecting the infrastructure of civil rights enforcement.” As she explains, “My own scholarship examines how Title VII enforcement actually works in practice. Putting that research in front of the Commission during a live rulemaking is exactly the kind of contribution scholars should be making.” Professor Lin agrees: “As professors, we felt deeply our obligation to ensure concepts at the core of our democracy remain accessible to the broader public. Our joint submission accomplished that.”