'Overqualified' is one of those words that ends a conversation, but I think it should spark further inquiry.
Professor Michael Conklin
Texas A&M University–Central Texas
Michael Conklin, Assistant Professor of Business Law at Texas A&M University–Central Texas, and Rafael Gely, the James E. Campbell Missouri Endowed Professor of Law at the University of Missouri School of Law, have published “Overqualified” as a Defense to Title VII Employment Protections in the Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal, offering employment litigators a framework for challenging an employer’s claim that it rejected an applicant because the applicant was “overqualified.”
Drawing on a circuit split over whether “overqualified” can serve as a proxy for age discrimination under the ADEA, Conklin and Gely show how plaintiffs’ lawyers can make a similar argument in race and sex discrimination cases under Title VII. An employer who invokes overqualification effectively concedes that the applicant was qualified, while explanations for rejecting the applicant anyway—concerns that the applicant will leave, become bored, or suffer from low morale—often depend on subjective and difficult-to-verify predictions that may mask discrimination. The authors show how litigators can use those weaknesses to challenge overqualification as pretext, while also developing a disparate-impact argument based on evidence that women and minorities may be especially likely to seek positions for which they are overqualified because caregiving responsibilities, limited geographic mobility, wealth disparities, and other structural constraints narrow their employment options.
The article urges courts to scrutinize overqualification defenses more closely and require employers to substantiate them with objective, job-related evidence. In the meantime, it gives plaintiffs’ lawyers arguments for persuading courts to look behind an ostensibly neutral claim of “overqualification” and ask whether it is instead serving as a proxy for discrimination.
In explaining his motivations for writing this article, Professor Conklin writes “Our goal was to show that ‘overqualified’ isn’t the harmless explanation it sounds like. Once you look at what it actually rests on, it’s much closer to discrimination than most people realize.” Professor Conklin proceeded to outline the effect he wants his article to have, stating “‘overqualified’ is one of those words that ends a conversation, but we think it should spark further inquiry.”