There has been a lot of confusion recently about the status of disparate impact doctrine. Our aim with this essay is to provide a clear roadmap of the arguments for practitioners.
Professor Olatunde Johnson, Columbia Law School
Professor Pauline Kim, Washington University School of Law
Professors Pauline T. Kim of Washington University School of Law and Olatunde Johnson of Columbia Law School have published Affirming the Constitutionality of Title VII Disparate Impact Doctrine: A Response to OLC in the Texas Law Review Online. The essay offers employment litigators a roadmap for defending disparate-impact liability against constitutional attack in the wake of a recent Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) opinion, which asserts that the doctrine is unconstitutional.
Kim and Johnson argue that the OLC opinion mischaracterizes disparate-impact doctrine as a “racial proportionality” mandate. Rather, longstanding Title VII doctrine simply asks whether an employment practice that disproportionately excludes a protected group is job-related and consistent with business necessity, and as the authors point out, the OLC has no evidence that this standard has forced employers to discriminate. Kim and Johnson contend that the Department’s opinion misreads the text and history of Title VII, ignoring Congress’s express codification of disparate-impact liability and decades of Supreme Court precedent applying and upholding the doctrine. In addition, the authors refute OLC’s claims of unconstitutionality, explaining that Congress has the constitutional power to regulate private employment, and further, that the Equal Protection Clause permits state actors to consider and mitigate exclusionary racial effects so long as they do not make race-based decisions about individual candidates or employees.
The essay arrives at a pivotal moment for employment discrimination law. Disparate impact has long been a central tool for challenging facially neutral hiring tests, selection criteria, and other workplace practices, and for encouraging employers to review their selection criteria and voluntarily remove arbitrary barriers. Kim and Johnson caution practitioners against treating the OLC opinion as binding legal authority, emphasizing that although it binds executive agencies, it has no such force in the courts. Their analysis provides lawyers with arguments for defending disparate-impact claims against constitutional attack, as well as for challenging future EEOC actions rooted in OLC’s reasoning under the Administrative Procedure Act.
In explaining their reasons for opining on this issue, the authors express their desire to assist in clearing out the recent noise and confusion regarding disparate impact litigation, reminding practitioners of the place disparate impact claims occupy within the landscape of employment discrimination suits. “There has been a lot of confusion recently about the status of disparate impact doctrine. Our aim with this essay is to provide a clear roadmap of the arguments for practitioners.”